Traditional Legal Model – God’s law is the rules He made to govern our behavior which, if transgressed, incur the legal penalty of death (Rom 6:23).
Biblical Healing Model – “law” is used in two major ways:
1. God’s law is the design template for life and is based on love, the defining characteristic of God, (“God is love” – 1 John 4:8) deviations from which, if not corrected, naturally end in death.
2. Specific laws were given as diagnostic tools (“By the law is the knowledge of sin” – Rom 3:20) to show man his condition – whether or not he is in harmony with God’s law/principal of love.
The difference within the Biblical Healing Model between laws as God’s design for life and laws as diagnostic tools is often (but not always) reflected in the use or non-use of the definite article “the” with “law.”
Is it “Law” or “The Law”?
Especially in Paul’s letter to the Romans, where there is much discussion about law, the absence or presence of the definite article “the” with “law” is significant. In Romans, “law” is used about 35 times with the article and about 40 times without.
One needs to check an interlinear version or consult a good commentary to determine whether the definite article is present or not in the original Greek because various Bible versions will add or omit it incorrectly.
When absent, the emphasis is generally on “law” as a principle (as in the first definition above under Biblical Healing Model). To say someone “disregards law” or “is a lawbreaker” says more about the attitude of the person than it does of a particular law broken by that person. The following two verses can easily be seen as speaking of law as a principle. In both cases, the definite article “the,” while appearing in the King James Version, is not present in the original. (I have crossed it out in the verses.)
“Owe no man any thing, but to love one another: for he that loveth another hath fulfilled the law.” (Rom 13:8)
“Love worketh no ill to his neighbour: therefore love is the fulfilling of the law.” (Rom 13:10)
When the article is present, it is speaking more often of law as a code of conduct or of particular laws (as in the second definition above under Biblical Healing Model).
“Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace; to the end the promise might be sure to all the seed; not to that only which is of the law, but to that also which is of the faith of Abraham; who is the father of us all,” (Rom 4:16)
In the verse above, “the law” can readily be understood to be a reference to the written law as it is used to distinguish a people to whom it as given as opposed to others who shared the faith of Abraham but were not his descendants.
The challenge is to determine whether it is present or absent in the original Greek as various translations often are not consistent in including or excluding the article as used in the original. Even knowing whether the article is present or not, sometimes the context must be carefully considered to make the distinction.
Modern Dictionary Definition
“Law (noun) The principles and regulations established in a community by some authority and applicable to its people, whether in the form of legislation or of custom and policies recognized and enforced by judicial decision.” (www.dictionary.com, accessed Dec. 30, 2017)
Webster’s 1828 Dictionary
“1. A rule, particularly an established or permanent rule, prescribed by the supreme power of a state to its subjects, for regulating their actions, particularly their social actions. Laws are imperative or mandatory, commanding what shall be done; prohibitory, restraining from what is to be forborn; or permissive, declaring what may be done without incurring a penalty. The laws which enjoin the duties of piety and morality, are prescribed by God and found in the Scriptures.”
“8. Moral law a law which prescribes to men their religious and social duties, in other words, their duties to God and to each other. The moral law is summarily contained in the decalogue or ten commandments, written by the finger of God on two tables of stone, and delivered to Moses on mount Sinai.” (http://webstersdictionary1828.com/Dictionary/law, accessed Dec. 30, 2017)
Of course, there are other meanings for law including natural law etc. Specific Divine laws also include:
• Directions regarding the sanctuary and its services
• Laws relating to personal relationships, marriage, slavery etc
• Laws about commerce, health, sanitation and agriculture
God’s Laws Not Legal
God’s law (principle) of other-centered love is not arbitrary. Death is the inherent result/natural consequence of self-centeredness which is a state of separation from God. Therefore, death is not a legal penalty, for the law simply declares reality. If uncorrected, a state of sin – living outside the law – results in final separation from God (Who is the source of life) and results in death. “The wages of sin is death …” (Rom 6:23). More verses saying this.
God’s laws regarding behavior can be understood as diagnostic tools. A hurtful act such as stealing shows a person to be self-centered rather than other-centered. Attempting to keep all the laws regarding behavior (while good) can never save (legalism does not work) because behavior is not the problem. The heart must be changed to be in harmony with the principle of other-centered love.
The Lenses/Paradigms Through Which Law is Understood
It also helps to understand God’s law by diagramming its function:
This difference in views of the role of law is further explained at: https://characterofgod.org/gospel-models-law/
Can Divine Laws be Changed?
The law of God as a principle reflects His very nature and is therefore, like Him, unchangeable. God’s laws regarding details of behavior (the diagnostic tools) can and do change as God deems necessary for our situation. They change because He does not. He always operates in accord with His key attribute of other-centered love. One example of law being changed is:
“For the priesthood being changed, there is made of necessity a change also of the law.” (Heb 7:12)
There are many examples of what have been termed divine accommodation.
A more thorough explanation of the role of divine law is given in this video.
A Wall of Protection (56 min) – the real role of God’s law.
Supplemental terms that are helpful in relation to law are:
Arbitrary adjective – “subject to individual will or judgment without restriction; contingent solely upon one’s discretion: an arbitrary decision.” (www.dictionary.com)
In the Traditional Legal Model, God, being sovereign, can make whatever laws He chooses and arbitrarily attach penalties for disobedience to them. This is opposed to God’s laws being consequential. Read a guest article with good examples of and discussion regarding arbitrary laws.
Consequential adjective – 1. following as an effect, result, or outcome; resultant; consequent. (www.dictionary.com)
God makes laws according to His nature and how He has designed creation to function. He does not assign arbitrary penalties for disobedience but there are natural consequences for transgression. Those consequences apply to what we call natural law (gravity etc) but also to any breaking of God’s law of love (acting selfishly) which ultimately leads, if uncorrected, to separation from God and thus death.
Legalism noun – 1. strict adherence, or the principle of strict adherence, to law or prescription, especially to the letter rather than the spirit.
1. the doctrine that salvation is gained through good works.
2. the judging of conduct in terms of adherence to precise laws. (www.dictionary.com)
The source adds that the word was first used in about 1830-40 explaining why it does not appear in Webster’s 1828 dictionary.
Legalism, the belief one can be saved by obeying laws meant only to regulate behavior and show the condition of the heart, was well-demonstrated by the Pharisees of Jesus’ day.